facebook
ClearView Logo
Home   •    Patient Resources   •    Blog

Exploring Clarity: LASIK vs. SMILE LASIK Eye Surgery

When it comes to vision correction, LASIK and SMILE LASIK are two popular options offering freedom from glasses and contact lenses. Both procedures use advanced technology to reshape the cornea and improve vision. However, knowing the differences between LASIK and SMILE LASIK is essential to make the right choice for your individual needs. In this blog, we’ll explore the key distinctions and help you understand which procedure might be best suited for you.


What is Lasik Eye Surgery

LASIK (Laser, Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis) is a very common surgical method of laser vision correction. The main objective of the operation is changing the shape of the cornea, the transparent outer layer of the eye, so that the eye will be able to focus properly. This reshaping corrects refractive errors such as myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism. The procedure utilizes a very precise laser to change the shape of the cornea, thus improving vision and allowing the patient to get by without glasses or contact lenses or at least with much less dependency on them. Whether you’re considering LASIK or Smile LASIK, it is very important to know deeply how LASIK works in order to be able to choose the right treatment for your vision requirements.


How Does LASIK Work

1. Flap Creation: The first step of a LASIK is making of a thin corneal flap. The flap is lifted & the tissue under the cornea is exposed.

2. Laser Reshaping: A very precise laser is then used to remove small layers of corneal tissue. The reshaping is done according to the vision prescription of the patient.

3. Flap Repositioning: The corneal flap is carefully put back in place after laser reshaping is done. The flap acts like a natural bandage during the healing process.


Advantages of LASIK

LASIK (Laser, assisted in situ keratomileusis) has a number of advantages over other types of vision correction surgery. Firstly, it is quick recovery time that most people will cite as the main benefit, as in most cases, patients notice better vision within a few hours. Secondly, LASIK has proved to be very efficient in correcting myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism.

Moreover, the operation time is short, and there is typically less pain involved than with conventional methods. In addition, LASIK has achieved such success over the years that it remains the preferred option for most people who want to cut down or totally get rid of their dependence on glasses or contact lenses. Still, when people are debating SMILE vs LASIK, it is usually the super precise nature of LASIK and the recovery time that are pointed out as the main advantages..


Disadvantages of LASIK

Even though LASIK is a very common and successful method of eye surgery, it does have a few potential drawbacks. The chief drawback that has been discussed is that LASIK might be incompatible with people who have thin corneas or suffer from certain eye conditions. Furthermore, a few patients report a range of short, lived side effects such as dry eyes, difficulty in seeing oncoming lights, or seeing halos around lights, especially during the nighttime. Also, a very small probability of being either under-corrected or over-corrected exists, in which case additional follow, up procedures would be necessary. In addition, LASIK surgery is generally considered more invasive than SMILE, hence the recovery time is likely to be longer. In essence, LASIK offers a lot of benefits; however, it is equally important to consider the drawbacks when deciding between eye surgery options such as LASIK vs SMILE.


What Is Smile Eye Surgery

SMILE, (Small Incision Lenticule Extraction) is a modern and minimally invasive laser vision correction procedure that has been gaining popularity in recent years. It is an advanced alternative to LASIK, designed to correct refractive errors with a unique technology. While traditional methods of LASIK involve creating a flap in the eye, SMILE uses only a small incision to remove the lenticule, which means benefits like faster healing and lower chances of complications. The discussion of SMILE vs LASIK is still on, going, but knowing the pros and cons of each procedure will help you make an informed decision for your vision correction.


How SMILE Works

1. Lenticule Creation: In the case of SMILE, a corneal flap is not required to be made in the cornea as is the case with LASIK. Rather, within the cornea, a small, lens-shaped piece of tissue is formed, which is referred to as a lenticule.

2. Incision and Extraction: The lenticule is accessed through a small incision, after which it is extracted through this incision. By doing this, the shape of the cornea is altered in a way that the refractive error is corrected.

3. No Flap Repositioning: As a corneal flap is not created in SMILE, there is no necessity for flap repositioning, thereby leading to a faster recovery.


Advantages of SMILE

Comparing SMILE vs LASIK, both surgeries provide great benefits for correcting one's vision yet the way they work is different.

SMILE is a minimally invasive kind of procedure and offers a faster recovery time which is why it is a very attractive option to a good number of people. In contrast, LASIK is a method that has been extensively used for a long time and is recognized as a very effective solution for the treatment of refractive errors.

The main difference between LASIK and SMILE is in their surgical methods and the recovery time involved, LASIK procedure may offer the possibility of faster results but the healing process might take longer. Both procedures come with their pros and cons, so getting to know the differences will be a big help in deciding which one suits you better.


Disadvantages of SMILE

The SMILE procedure is not without its drawbacks when comparing to LASIK. The first and foremost drawback of it is the limited capability of it being able to correct higher degrees of refractive errors. In simple words, SMILE will most likely be less effective if a person's myopia or astigmatism is very high. The SMILE recovery time can also be a little bit longer than LASIK and performing the operation requires a highly specialized surgeon with a lot of expertise. Furthermore, SMILE is not capable of completely addressing presbyopia as LASIK can.

Despite these drawbacks, a lot of people still decide to have SMILE because it is a less invasive surgical procedure and has a lower chance of causing dry eyes. When it comes to SMILE vs LASIK, it is ultimately about each person's needs and what they prefer. For some people, the benefits of LASIK such as quick recovery, are more important than the benefits of theSMILE procedure.


Similarities Between LASIK and SMILE

  • Refractive surgery options: Both LASIK and SMILE are advanced refractive procedures designed to treat common vision issues like nearsightedness, farsightedness, and astigmatism.
  • Laser-based technology: Both procedures utilize precise laser technology to reshape the cornea for improved vision.
  • Minimal recovery time: While smile vs lasik recovery time may vary, both procedures offer faster healing compared to traditional methods like glasses or contacts.
  • Long-term effectiveness: Both LASIK and SMILE offer long-term improvements in vision with a high success rate.
  • Outpatient procedure: Neither LASIK nor SMILE requires an overnight stay; both are performed as outpatient surgeries with quick recovery.
  • Minimal pain: How does LASIK work? Both procedures are relatively pain-free, with the patient typically experiencing only mild discomfort post-surgery.


Comparing the Two Procedures

  1. Flap or No Flap: The biggest difference between LASIK and SMILE is that one creates a corneal flap and the other doesn't. In LASIK there is a flap, but in SMILE it is left untouched. The lack of a flap in SMILE helps in lowering the chances of getting complications of flap displacement.
  2. Minimally Invasive Nature: Some people are thinking that SMILE is less invasive than LASIK because of the smaller size of the incision in the former. Thus, it may turn out to be a faster recovery, less pain, and fewer symptoms of dry eyes.
  3. Thin Corneas: Those who have thin corneas may consider SMILE more appropriate as it preserves more corneal tissue than LASIK. This could be a decisive factor for people with borderline corneal thickness.
  4. Vision Correction Range: LASIK is capable of treating a wider range of vision problems than SMILE. LASIK is generally the first choice for patients with high refractive errors or complicated vision problems.
  5. Recovery Time: Both LASIK and SMILE allow you to get back to your daily routine very quickly. Besides that, SMILE is slightly superior in terms of recovery time, usually it takes about 1 to 3 days to fully recover from the SMILE surgery, while recovery after LASIK surgery lasts about a week on average. This is because the healing process is more rapid due to no flap being involved.

Choosing the Right Procedure for You

Choosing between LASIK and SMILE should be primarily based on your vision needs as well as the specific features of your eyes. A detailed eye examination along with a discussion with a skilled surgeon will help you in deciding the appropriate treatment. Your lifestyle, for instance, hobbies, work, and preferences, also influence the choice. For instance, athletes who play physical sports might opt for SMILE which is a flapless procedure. Also, people with thin corneas might be better off with SMILE, however, it is a professional who can measure the cornea's thickness and suggest the best option for the patient.


FAQs

Q1. Is SMILE better than LASIK for dry eyes?

Ans. SMILE may be considered a better choice for dry eye patients, as it tends to cause less dryness than LASIK. This is because SMILE does not require making a corneal flap, which sometimes is blamed for reduced tear production.

Q2. What is the success rate of SMILE?

Ans. The success rate of SMILE is very good. For example, clinical trials report that approximately 95% of patients achieve a vision of 20/25 or better after the procedure. On the other hand, SMILE is still less conventional than LASIK so future studies are needed to verify the longevity of results.

Q3. How long is the smile vs. LASIK recovery time?

Ans. Generally, LASIK recovery is quicker, and many patients are able to resume their normal routines after just one or two days. SMILE might take a bit longer, and most people report feeling completely rejuvenated after about 2 to 4 days.

Q4. What is the SMILE and LASIK alternative?

Ans. Both SMILE and LASIK alternatives can be considered PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy), which also alters the cornea, but where no corneal flap is created. PRK might be the right choice for people with thin corneas or who are not suitable for LASIK or SMILE.


Conclusion

LASIK and SMILE eye surgeries represent remarkable advancements in the field of vision correction, offering individuals the opportunity to enjoy life without the constraints of glasses or contact lenses. While LASIK has a longer track record and a broader range of applications, SMILE stands out for its minimally invasive approach and quicker recovery time.

Ultimately, the choice between LASIK and SMILE depends on various factors, including individual vision needs, lifestyle considerations, and the specific characteristics of your eyes. Consulting with an experienced eye surgeon is crucial to making an informed decision that aligns with your unique circumstances, ensuring a clearer and brighter future without the reliance on corrective eyewear.

GET STARTED WITH CLEARVIEW

Schedule your free consultation with Dr. Sandy T. Feldman or Dr. Michael. L Mathison to discover how achieving visual freedom can change your life.

Google Logo
Facebook logo large
Facebook Logo
Yelp Logo